Sill & Rafter

Heating, Cooling & Energy · Calculator

Dual Fuel Heat Pump Break-Even Calculator

Enter your fuel and its price, the furnace or boiler efficiency and your electricity price. The calculator gives the break-even COP: above it the heat pump is the cheaper heat. Add the heat pump's rated COPs at 47 °F and 17 °F to estimate the outdoor temperature where that happens.

From your bill: the total minus fixed charges, divided by the units used.

Without the fixed monthly charge.

Optional, from the maker's performance data or the AHRI certificate.

Break-even COP

3.2

Heat from the natural gas
$15.58 per million Btu
Heat pump at the break-even COP
$15.58 per million Btu
Electric resistance heat
$49.82 per million Btu

Above this COP the heat pump is the cheaper heat; below it, the furnace or boiler.

Never set the switchover below the temperature where the heat pump can no longer heat the house on its own.

NRCan heat pump sizing guide, Equation 6; EIA heat contents.

With natural gas at 1.48 dollars a therm in a 95 percent furnace and electricity at 0.17 dollars per kWh, a heat pump is the cheaper heat while its COP stays above 3.2. For a unit rated 3.61 at 47 °F and 2.67 at 17 °F, that is down to about 34 °F.

Two balance points

A dual-fuel system pairs a heat pump with a furnace or boiler. Two temperatures decide when the furnace runs. The thermal balance point is where the heat pump can no longer keep the house warm on its own. The economic balance point is where its heat starts costing more than the furnace's, because a heat pump's COP falls as the outdoor air gets colder. ComEd's switchover guide warns never to set the switchover below the thermal balance point.

The break-even COP

Natural Resources Canada's heat pump sizing guide gives the minimum COP for the heat pump to be cheaper (its Equation 6): electricity price × furnace efficiency ÷ fuel price × the kWh of heat in one unit of fuel. Use prices without the fixed monthly charges, which you pay either way.

FuelHeat per unitkWh per unit
Natural gas, therm100,000 Btu29.31
Natural gas, 100 cubic feet103,600 Btu30.36
Propane, gallon91,452 Btu26.80
Heating oil, gallon138,500 Btu40.59
Natural gas, cubic meter10.36
Propane, liter7.03
Heating oil, liter10.61

The US figures are the EIA's (1,036 Btu per cubic foot of gas, 3,412 Btu per kWh); the metric ones are the Canadian guide's Table 8.

From COP to an outdoor temperature

Makers publish the COP at standard test temperatures, including 47 °F and 17 °F, on their data sheets and AHRI certificates. The calculator draws a straight line between those two points to find where the COP meets the break-even value. Real heat pumps do not follow a perfect line, so the maker's full performance table, plotted against your break-even COP, gives a closer answer.

Questions people ask

What COP does a heat pump need to beat a gas furnace?

It depends on prices. With gas at 1.48 dollars a therm, a 95 percent furnace and electricity at 17 cents, the heat pump wins while its COP is above about 3.2.

What is the balance point of a dual fuel system?

There are two: the thermal balance point, where the heat pump alone can no longer heat the house, and the economic one, where its heat costs more than the furnace's. The switchover should not be set below the thermal one.

Is propane or oil backup different?

Only through the numbers: enter the price per gallon or liter and the furnace or boiler efficiency, and the calculator uses that fuel's heat content.

Sources